The Time He Said “Love” and I Lost All Critical Thinking Skills

It started with an accent, and suddenly, all my decision-making skills evaporated. By the time he said “love,” I knew what I was going to do.

If nothing else, I can confidently say I’ve lived my Notting Hill fantasy — minus the happy ending, plus a slightly awkward goodbye kiss.

It was college, a night out with all my friends at a bar, and I was minding my own business — until I heard it. That accent. You know the kind: effortlessly charming, a little posh, like every word he said could be the opening line to a rom-com. I don’t even remember what he looked like exactly. He was older, not really my type, and honestly, not even that cute, but my brain completely checked out. All I knew was that I needed to talk to him.

Before I knew it, I was clinging to him like my life depended on it.

My friends were staring at me like I’d lost my mind, whispering questions I couldn’t hear over the pounding of the music and the fact that my mouth was pressed to his. I was on a mission, and nothing else mattered.

We left the bar together in a classic New York yellow cab and ended up at the hotel he was staying in.

The sex itself? Mediocre at best. But here’s the thing: I didn’t care.

I closed my eyes the whole time, savoring that accent as if it were Harry Styles above me.

When he finally asked if I wanted to open them, I shook my head and smiled. Nope. I was there for the voice, for the plot — and nothing else. Call me shallow, call me extra, but it was a bucket-list check, and I owned it.

A few days later, he somehow booked us a hotel room again.

This time, the soundtrack was Harry Potter playing softly in the background. We went through the motions, I got my “accent fix,” and then… nothing. Radio silence. No texts, no calls, no follow-ups.

I remember lying there thinking: Well, that was fun. And maybe a little ridiculous?

He booked the hotel smack dab in the middle of Times Square, so as I left, I was met with bright lights and thousands of people with no idea what I had just done. I got myself a slice of pizza and made my way home.

Looking back, it wasn’t about love, connection, or even the sex. It was about a story I wanted to live through — one of those moments you’ll remember years later and laugh about with your friends.

And honestly? I don’t regret a second of it. I might even do it again.

Welcome to our new column at The Girly Pop Register that is strictly for the girls. Indulge in all life has to offer here.